Carter was the third of three children born to Ronald and Brenda Carter of Birmingham. He was a drum major for the Phillips High School marching band and graduated in 1993. He went on to study at Liberty University in Lynchburg, Virginia before enlisting in the U.S. Air Force in 1996. He was assigned to Offutt Air Force Base in Omaha, Nebraska where he met his wife, Tiphanie.
From 1997 to 2000 Carter worked as a corrections officer for the Douglas County Sheriff's Department in Omaha. He returned to Alabama to work in corrections for the Shelby County Sheriff's Office. From 2002 to 2007 he worked as an officer in the Leeds Police Department, then as a detective, sergeant, and member of the Special Response Team at the Fairfield Police Department. He also was licensed as a minister and worked as a youth pastor.
Carter joined the Birmingham Police Department on July 18, 2011 and has been assigned to the West Precinct, High Intensity Community Oriented Police Patrol (HICOPP), and as a school resource officer for the Youth Services Unit at Jackson-Olin High School and Woodlawn High School.
Early in the morning of Sunday, January 13, 2019 Carter responded to a call for back-up when patrol officer Lucas Allums, working undercover to investigate car break-ins, saw two males appearing to try car door handles on the 900 block of 5th Avenue North, near the 4 Seasons Bar & Grill. They approached one of the suspects, Jeremy Elwin Owens, and began patting him down. When they found what they believed to be a weapon, they asked about it. Owens then grabbed his gun and began firing at the officers. Both were struck, and one of the suspects was wounded by return fire. All three were taken to UAB Hospital where Carter was pronounced dead and Allums spent nine days in intensive care for a critical injury. A second 18-year-old suspect was taken into custody at the scene but later released without being charged. Owens was formally charged on January 25 and released from hospital care to police custody in early February. The Alabama Law Enforcement Agency is reviewing the incident.
- Robinson, Carol (January 13, 2019) "Slain Birmingham officer Sgt. Wytasha Carter ‘wanted to make a difference’." The Birmingham News
- Robinson, Carol (January 14, 2019) "Governor orders flags flown at half-staff following shooting death of Birmingham police Sgt. Wytasha Carter." The Birmingham News
- "WyTasha Lamar Carter" obituary (January 20, 2019) The Birmingham News
- Robinson, Carol (February 14, 2019) "Felon charged with capital murder in shooting death of Birmingham police Sgt. Wytasha Carter." The Birmingham News