2019 Birmingham special election
The 2019 Birmingham special election was a city wide election held on October 8, 2019 to determine whether to renew the existing municipal property tax rate of 9.8 mills, and to fill vacancies in three Birmingham City Council seats.
The Birmingham Election Commission met in May to set a date for the city-wide referendum. Under the requirements of the Mayor-Council Act, any vacant seats on the City Council, including those held by acting appointees, also had to be filled during the city-wide election.
Candidates could submit qualifications for open Council seats between August 9 and 23. On election day, approximately 15,713 votes were recorded, approximately 10.8% of registered voters city-wide.
After polls closed, workers at three precincts mistakenly sealed the data cards from the vote scanners with the paper ballots. A court order was required to unseal those packets and retrieve the data cards, meaning that the unofficial results of the election were not available until Wednesday afternoon.
The overwhelming result of the referendum was a renewal of all three taxes for a term of 25 years. All three incumbents retained their seats. Clinton Woods and Crystal Smitherman won outright, and Wardine Alexander advanced to a run-off against Ray Brooks. She won the runoff for District 7 on November 19.
Results
Property Tax referenda
The referendum was divided into separate votes on three ad valorum taxes, first imposed in 1979, renewed for 30 years in 1991, and set to expire on September 30, 2021. The first, a 4.2 mill tax, was designated "for public school use." The second, a 2.8 mill tax, "for debt service of school bonds", and the third, also 2.8 mills, "for public school operations." The school taxes represented approximately 54% of all property tax revenues collected in the city, and then averaged about $27 million per year.
- Proposition 1 (4.2 mills)
- Yes 14,145 votes (90.0%)
- No 1,568 votes (10.0%)
- Proposition 2 (2.8 mills)
- Yes 14,128 votes (90.0%)
- No 1,564 votes (10.0%)
- Proposition 3 (2.8 mills)
- Yes 13,993 votes (89.2%)
- No 1,696 votes (10.8%)
Birmingham City Council
- Birmingham City Council District 1:
- Clinton Woods (incumbent): 1,764 votes (71.3%), winner
- Sherman Collins: 670 votes (27.1%)
- Haki Jamaal Muhammad: 41 votes (1.7%)
- Birmingham City Council District 6:
- Crystal Smitherman (incumbent): 1,287 votes (51.5%), winner
- Onoyemi Williams: 380 votes (15.2%)
- Carlos Chaverst: 349 votes (14.0%)
- Latanya Millhouse: 265 votes (10.6%)
- Clarence Muhammad: 127 votes (5.1%)
- Willine Body: 50 votes (2.0%)
- Keith Williams: 41 votes (1.6%)
- Birmingham City Council District 7:
- Wardine Alexander (incumbent): 1,159 votes (42.4%), 869 votes (53.6%) in runoff, winner
- Ray Brooks: 844 votes (30.9%), 751 votes (46.4%) in runoff
- Lonnie Malone: 730 votes (26.7%)
References
- Prickett, Sam (April 23, 2019) "Referendum on Renewing Property Tax for Birmingham Schools Possible, Up for Discussion Next Week." BirminghamWatch
- Koplowitz, Howard (May 6, 2019) "Birmingham sets Oct. 8 special election for 3 council seats." The Birmingham News
- Koplowitz, Howard (August 6, 2019) "Candidate qualifying dates set for Birmingham council special elections." The Birmingham News
- Beahm, Anna (August 26, 2019) "Who qualified for Oct. 8 election for three Birmingham council seats?" The Birmingham News
- "Special Tax Election Frequently Asked Questions" (November 20, 2019) Birminghamal.gov press release
- Beahm, Anna (September 20, 2019) "Tax votes coming up in Mountain Brook, Birmingham." The Birmingham News
- Wright, Erica (October 3, 2019) "Meet City Council Candidates in Tuesday’s Birmingham Special Election." The Birmingham Times
- Beahm, Anna (October 9, 2019) "Missing results retrieved from sealed Birmingham ballot boxes." The Birmingham News
- Beahm, Anna (October 9, 2019) "Birmingham renews school tax; District 7 goes to runoff in November." The Birmingham News
- Beahm, Anna (November 19, 2019) "Alexander wins Birmingham City Council District 7 runoff election." The Birmingham News